Maiden.bet

Columbus Predictions & Picks — October 2, 2026

By The Maiden Desk · October 2, 2026

Every number below was fixed before the match and graded against the official result.

Share card

2 matches are on Friday's card at Columbus, and we have a pick for every one of them. The headline act: Keegan Smith against Mitchell Krueger in the quarterfinal. Our calls: Smith over Krueger, Shelbayh over Mayo.

A. Mayo vs Abedallah Shelbayh

✓ Pick rightThis one lands on the correct side of the ledger: 63% on Abedallah Shelbayh, who won 7-6 7-5.

Pick: Shelbayh

Win probability: 63% Shelbayh · Market: -112 · We call it in 3 sets (52%) · single likeliest score 2-1 (32%)

A. Mayo and Abedallah Shelbayh meet in the quarterfinal at Columbus on Friday. Abedallah Shelbayh comes in at 6 wins from the last ten. A. Mayo comes in at 3 wins from the last ten.

Abedallah Shelbayh is clearly higher-rated on hard — our number puts Shelbayh around 63%. Mayo comes in off a compressed schedule; Shelbayh comes in off a compressed schedule. Shelbayh should have enough here, though Mayo has the tools to make the scoreboard uncomfortable.

Keegan Smith vs Mitchell Krueger

✗ Pick wrongWe got this one wrong. Our final number was 54% on Keegan Smith; Mitchell Krueger won 6-4 7-6.

Pick: Smith

Win probability: 54% Smith · Market: -127 · We call it in 3 sets (46%) · single likeliest score 2-0 (30%)

Friday's Columbus quarterfinal pits Keegan Smith against Mitchell Krueger on hard. Keegan Smith is 6-4 across recent matches. Mitchell Krueger has won 6 of the last 10.

On paper it's close: comparable ratings, comparable serve numbers, small margins everywhere. Smith comes in off a compressed schedule; Krueger comes in off a compressed schedule. A tiebreak or two would surprise nobody, with Smith fractionally more likely to land the big points.

Get the free ebook + tomorrow's picks

Sign up for the daily desk email and our nine-chapter beginner's guide to trading sports prediction markets comes free as a PDF. One email a day with the day's free picks in full, unsubscribe anytime.

Updated Oct 2, 2026, 5:01 AM UTC. Picks are frozen before first serve and graded on the track record page — this page is never edited after the fact.